Grounding Tips,
Shielding, Noise, Interference, Reflections, Repeaters and more
Introduction
The coexistence of
equipment of different technologies and the inadequacy of the installations
favors the emission of electro-magnetic energy and often causes problems of
electro-magnetic compatibility.
EMI is the energy that
causes undesirable response to any equipment and may be generated by sparking
on the motor brushes, tension circuits switching, activation of inductive and
resistive loads, activation of switches, circuit breakers, fluorescent bulbs,
heaters, automotive ignitions, atmospheric discharges and even the
electrostatic discharge between persons and equipment, microwaves devices,
mobile communication equipment etc. All this may provoke alterations with the
resulting overload, sub-voltage, peaks, voltage transients etc., which may
cause high impact on a communication network. This is very common in industries
and factories, where EMI is fairly frequent in function of the larger use of
machines such as welding instruments, motors (MCCs) and in digital networks and
computers in the vicinity of these areas.
The biggest problem
caused by EMI is the occasional situations that slowly degrade the equipment
and its components. Many different problems may be generated by EMI on
electronic equipment as communication failures between devices of the same
equipment network and/or computers, alarms produced without explanation, action
on relays that do not follow logic, without being commanded, in addition to the
burning of electronic components and circuits etc. It is very common the
occurrence of noises in power source lines due to bad grounding and shielding
or even error in the project.
The topology and the
distribution of the wiring, types of cables, proctection
techniques are factors that must be considered to minimize the EMI effects.
Keep in mind that in high frequencies the cables work as a transmission system
with crossed and confused lines, reflect and scatter energy from one circuit to
another. Keep the connections in good conditions. Innactive
connectors may develop resistance or become RF detectors.
A typical example of how
the EMI may affect the work of an electronic component is a capacitor exposed
to a voltage peak higher than its specified nominal voltage. This may
deteriorate the dielectric, whose width is limited by the capacitor operation
voltage, which may produce a gradient of potential inferior to the dielectric
rigidity of the material, causing malfunctioning and even the capacitor
burning. Or, still, the transistor polarization currents may be altered and
cause their saturation or cut, or burn its components by the joule effect,
depending on the intensity.
This article will show
some details about Profibus, grounding, shielding,
noises, interferences, reflections and much more.
In
measurements:
Quite often the reliability of a control system is
jeopardized by its poor installations. Commonly, users tolerate them but a
close look reveals problems involving cables, their courses and packing,
shielding and grounding.
It is extremely important that every person involved is
aware and conscious and moreover committed with the plant operational
reliability and personal safety.
Reliability of an automation and control system
Many requirements should be followed to ensure the
several level of reliability, including:
There is a direct relationship between reliability
and costs, but, more than this, safety and costs, where, somehow, technical
negligence may happen.
NBR 5410
NBR-5410 is the Brazilian standard covering low voltage
electrical installations. This regulation guides how to configure and calculate
grounding systems, as well as equipotential points to connect electric,
electronic and lightning-protection systems.
Complementary regulations:
The concept of grounding
Grounding is the intentional connection of an equipment
or system to the ground so that it provides a safe and low resistance path.
Important:
Ground wire
Every circuit must have a conductor for protection all
through its length.
Grounding in Sensitive
Electric Equipment
Grounding systems must
execute multiple simultaneous functions: provide personal safety and protect
the equipment. To summarize, here is a list of their basic functions:
The neutral conductor is
normally insulated and the power source system must be the TN-S (T: directly
grounded point; N: masses directly connected to the grounded power source
point; S: different conductor for neutral and protection).
The neutral conductor
works basically as a means of conducting system return currents.
The protection conductor
basically bonds the mass currents to earth. All the housings must be connected
to the protection conductor.
The equipotential
conductor is the electronic circuit reference potential.
Figure 1 – TN-S System
In order to meet the
previous functions three fundamental features are enhanced:
1. Conductive capacity;
2. Low resistance value;
3. Configuration of an
electrode that enables the potential gradient control.
Regardless of its
protective or functional aim, grounding must be a single one on each
installation spot. There are situations where earthing
wires may be separated, however with precautions.
In relation to the
installation of grounding system components some criteria must be obeyed:
Equipotentialize
Definition: Equalize with
the same potential.
In practice: Minimize the
potential difference to reduce accidents.
Each building must have a
principal equipotentialization and the installation
masses located in the same edification must be connected to the main one,
thereby creating the same and only grounding electrode. See figures 2 and 3.
The functional equipotentialization equalizes the grounding and guarantees
that the signal circuits and the electromagnetic compatibility work well.
Conductor for Equipotentialization
1. Main – there must be at
least half section of the protection conductor with the largest section and at
least:
1. 6mm2 (Copper);
2. 16mm2 (Aluminum);
3. 50mm2 (Steel)
Figure 2 - Equipotentialization
Figure 3 – Grounding Line and Equipotential
Figure 4 – Equipotential Material
Considerations about equipotentials
Figure 5 shows a
generating source for high voltage and high frequency noises, besides a system
for temperature measuring 23 m distant from the control room. Depending on how
the signals are accommodated there might be up to 2.3KV at the measuring
terminals. As the conditions for shielding, grounding and equalization improve,
we reach the ideal measuring conditions.
Figure 5 – Example of how
important are grounding and equipotentialization and
their influence on the signal
In distributed systems
like industrial process control, with distant physical areas and power supplied
by different power sous, it is recommended grounding on each location and to
apply EMI control techniques on each signal routing, as shown on figure 2.
Implications of poor
grounding
The implications of poor
or even inadequate grounding are not limited to safety aspects. The main
effects of inadequate grounding are electric shocks to users through contact,
low or intermittent response from the protection systems, such as fuses,
circuit breakers etc.).
However, other
operational problems may be caused by inefficient grounding:
The grounding system must
be single and must satisfy different purposes:
The result is that
equipment with metal housing is subject to noise on the power source and
lightning grounding loops.
In order to meet the
safety standards and protection against lightning and EMI the grounding system
should be a zero impedance plan, whose mixture of different current levels
would turn these systems free from interference. This would be the ideal
condition, one that, however, is not necessarily true in practice.
Types of Grounding
In terms of process
industry the following grounding types can be identified:
Note: the “chassis” or
“housing” grounding is used as a protection against electric shock. This type
of grounding is not a zero-resistance type and its potential may vary. However,
the loops are mostly connected to the ground to prevent shock risks.
Single-point grounding
The grounding system at a
single point can be seen on figure 6, whose striking feature is a single
grounding point evenly distributed to the entire installation.
This configuration is
best suitable for low-frequency spectrum and satisfies perfectly high frequency
electronic systems installed in reduced areas.
Moreover, this system
must be insulated not to work as a return path for signal currents circulating
through signal conductors with balanced pair, for example.
This type of parallel
grounding eliminates the common impedance problem, although detrimental to the
use of a pile of wiring. Furthermore, the impedance on each wire may be too
high and the ground lines may become a source of noise in the system. This
situation may be minimized by choosing the right type of conductor (AWG 14
type). Cables with thicker gauge help reduce the ground resistance, while the
flexible wire reduces the earth impedance.
Multiple-point grounding
For high frequencies, the
multipoint system is the most adequate and simplifies the installation, as
shown on figure 7.
Figure 7 a – Multipoint grounding
Figure 7 b – Grounding in
practice
Many low impedance
connections between the PE conductors and the grounding electrodes combined
with multiple-impedance paths between the electrodes and the impedance on
conductors create a complex grounding system with an impedance network (see
figure 7 b), and the currents that flow through it cause different grounding
potentials on the the network interconnections.
The multipoint grounding
systems that use balanced circuits normally do not have noise problems due to
filtering, where the noise field is limited between the cable and the grounding
plan.
Figure 8 – Inadequate
multipoint grounding
Figure 9 – Inadequate
single-point grounding
Figure 9 shows adequate
grounding whose individual currents are conducted to a single grounding point.
Serial grounding
connection is very common because it is simple and economical. However, this
grounding provides a “dirty ground” due to the common impedance between the
circuits. When the circuits share the same ground wire, the circuit currents
that flow through the finite impedance of the common base line may cause ground
potential variations on the other circuits. If the currents are large enough,
the potential variations may cause serious disturbances on the operation of all
the circuits connected to the common signal ground.
Grounding loops
A grounding loop occurs
when there is more than a grounding path, which generates undesirable currents
between these points.
These paths form the
equivalent to an antenna loop that captures the interference currents with high
efficience.
Consequently, the voltage
reference becomes unstable and the noise appears on the signals.
Figure 10 – Grounding
loop
Grounding at equipment
level: Practice
In practice, the resource
is to use a “mixed system” that separates similar circuits and segregates those
with the noise level:
1. “signal ground” for more
sensitive circuits;
2. “noise
ground” for commands (relays), high potency circuits (MCCs, for example).
3. “equipment
ground” for rack , panel grounding, etc.These
three circuits are connected to the protection conductor.
These three circuits are
connected to the protection conductor.
Figure 11 – Grounding at
equipment level in practice
The signals may vary
basically due to:
The main sources of
interference are:
Capacitive Coupling
The capacitive coupling
is represented by the interaction of electric fields between conductors. A
conductor passes near a noise source (the disturber), captures this noise and
sends it to another part of the circuit (the victim). This capacitance effect
between two bodies with electric loads separated by a dielectric is called
mutual capacitance effect.
The electric field effect
is proportional to the frequency and inversely proportional to the distance.
The level of disturbance
depends on the voltage variations (dv/dt) and the
value of the coupling capacitance between the “disturber cable” and the “victim
cable”.
The coupling capacitance
increases with:
Figure 12 a – Capacitive
coupling effect
Figure 12 b – Example of
capacitive coupling effect
Figure 13 shows the
coupling and its voltage and current sources in common and differential modes.
Differential Mode Common
Mode Source Victim
Figure 13 – Differential
mode and common mode – Capacitive coupling
Measures to reduce the
capacitive coupling effect
1. Limit the cable length
that runs in parallel
2. Increase the distance
between the disturber cable and the victim cable
3. Ground one of the shield
ends on both sides
4. Reduce the disturber
signal on the dv/dt by increasing the signal
peak whenever possible (lower the signal frequency)
Always wrap the conductor
or equipment with metal material (Faraday shield). The ideal is to cover 100%
of the protected part and to ground this shield so that the parasite capacitance
between the conductor and the shield does not function as a repowering or
crosstalk element. Figure 14 shows the interference between cables whose
capacitive coupling induces voltage transients, such as electrostatic pickups.
In this situation the interference current is drained by the shield to the
ground, without affecting the signal levels.
Figure 14 – Interference
between cables: the capacitive coupling between cables induces voltage
transients (electrostatic pickups)
Figure 15 shows an example
of protection against transients.
Figure 15- Example of
protection against transients (best solution against
Foucault current)
How to reduce
electrostatic interferences:
1. Adequate grounding and
shields
2. Optical Insulation
3. Use of conduits and grounded
metal boxesFigure 16 shows the capacitance on the
coupling between two conductors separated by a D distance.
Figure 16 shows the
capacitance on the coupling between two conductors separated by a D distance.
Figure 16 – Capacitive
coupling between conductors at a D distance
Inductive Coupling
The “disturber cable” and
the “victim cable” are followed by a magnetic field. The level of disturbance
depends on the current variations (di/dt) and the
mutual coupling inductance. The inductive coupling increases with:
Figure 17 a – Inductive
coupling between conductors
Measures to reduce the
inductive coupling effect between cables
1. Limit the length of
cables running in parallel
2. Increase the distance
between the disturber cable and the victim cable
3. Ground one of the shield
ends between the two cables
4. Reduce the dv/dt on the disturber cable by increasing the signal peak,
whenever possible (resistors connected in series, PTC resistors on the
disturber cable, ferrite rings in the disturbers and/or the victim cable)
Figure 18 – Inductive
coupling between cable and field
Measures to reduce the
inductive coupling effect between cable and field
1. Limit the cable “h”
height to the gound plan
2. Whenever possible install
the cable close to the metal surface
3. Use twisted cables
4. Use ferrites and EMI
cables
Figure 19 – Inductive
coupling between cable and ground loop
Measures to reduce the
effect of the inductive coupling between cable and ground loop
1. Reduce the “h” height and
the cable length.
2. Whenever possible locate
the cable near the metal surface.
3. Use twisted wires.
4. In high frequencies
ground the shield on two points (caution!) and in low frequencies on a single
point.
|
Digital Communication Cable |
Cables with and without shield: 60Vdc ou 5Vac
e < 400Vac |
Cables with and without shield> 400Vac |
Any cable subject to lightning exposure |
Digital Communication Cable |
|
10 cm |
20 cm |
50 cm |
Cables with and without shield: 60Vdc ou 25Vac e< 400Vac |
10 cm |
|
10 cm |
50 cm |
Cables with and without shield: > 400Vac |
20 cm |
10 cm |
|
50 cm |
Any cable subject to lightning exposure |
50 cm |
50 cm |
50 cm |
|
Table 1 – Distances between digital communication cables and other types
of cable to ensure EMI protection
Figure 20 – Interference
between cables: magnetic fields through inductive coupling between cables
induce current transients (electromagnetic pickups)
Electromagnetic
Interferences can be reduced with:
1. Twisted cable
2. Optical Insulation
3. Use of grounded metal
ducts and boxes
Figure 21 – Mutual
inductance between two conductors
To minimize the induction
effect use the twisted pair cable that reduces the (S) area and the Vb inducted voltage in function of the B field, thereby
balancing the effects (average of the effects according to distances):
The twisted pair cable is
formed by two pairs of wire. The one-pair wire is wound in spiral and through
the cancellation effect reduce the noise and keep the medium electric
properties constant through its whole length.
The reduction effect by
using twisted wires is efficient for cancelling the flow, called Rt (in dB):
Rt = -20 log{(1/(
2nl +1 ))*[1+2nlsen(/nλ)]}
dB ,
where n is
the number of turns per meter and l is the cable total
length. See figure 22a and figure 22b.
The cancelling effect
reduces the crosstalk between the twisted pairs and the level of
electromagnetic/radiofrequency interference. The number of wire twists may vary
for reducing the electric coupling. Its construction provides a capacitive
coupling between the pair conductors. It works more efficiently in low
frequencies (< 1 MHz). When not shielded, it has the disadvantage with
common-mode noise. On low frequencies, i. e., when the cable length is smaller
than 1/20 of the wave length of the noise frequency, the shield will present
the same potential along its entire extension, and the shield should be
connected on a single ground point. On high frequencies when the cable length
is longer than 1/20 of the wave length of the noise fequency,
the shield will present high sensibility to noise and the grounding on both
shield ends is recommended.
On the inductive coupling
we will have Vnoise = 2πBAcosα
where B is the field and α is the angle where the flow crosses the area (A)
vector, or still in function of the mutual M inductance: Vruído
= 2πfMI, whose I is the current on
the power source cable.
Figure 22 a – Inductive
coupling effect in parallel cables
Figure 22 b –
Minimization of the inductive coupling effect in twisted cables
Figure 22 c – Example of
inductive noise
Figure 22 d – Example of Profibus Cables near the power source cable
The use of twisted pair
cables is very efficient as long as the induction in each tortion
area is approximately equal to the adjacent induction. Its use is efficient in
differential mode, balanced circuits and has low efficiency in low frequencies
on unbalanced circuits. In high frequency circuits with grounded multipoints, the efficiency is high, since the return
current tends to flow through the adjacent return. However, in common mode high
frequencies the cable has little efficiency.
Figure 23 details the Profibus-DP and the ground loops situation.
Figure 23 – Profibus-DP and the ground loops
Protection with metal
ducts
Following is the use of
metal ducts to minimize Foucault currents.
The spacing between ducts
induces the magnetic field to generate disturbances. In addition, this
discontinuity may help ease the difference of potential between each duct
segment, and, in the event of current surge generated by an atmosphere
discharge or a short circuit, the lack of continuity will not allow the current
to circulate along the aluminum duct and consequently will not protect the Profibus cable.
The ideal is to connect
each segment with the largest possible contact area to provide more
protection against electromagnetic induction and also a conductor between each
segment on each duct side, with the shortest possible length to ensure an
alternative path to the currents, in case of the increase of resistance at the
segment joints.
If the aluminum duct is
properly mounted, when the magnetic field penetrates on the aluminum plate will
produce inside it a a
magnetic flow that varies in function of the time [f = a.sen(w.t)],
creating an induced f.e.m. [ E = - df/dt = a.w.cos(w.t)].
In high frequencies the f.e.m induced on the aluminum plate will be higher,
originating a larger magnetic field and will cancel almost completely the
magnetic field generated by the power source cable. This cancellation effect is
smaller in low frequencies. In high frequencies the cancellation is more
efficient.
This is the effect of
metal plates and screens on the incidence of electromagnetic waves; they
generate their own fields that minimize or even nullify the field through them,
therefore working as true shields against electromagnetic waves. They work as a
Faraday cage.
Make sure that the plates
and the coupling joints are made with the same material as the cable
ducts/boxes. Protect the connecting points against corrosion after mounting
with zinc paint or varnish.
Although the cables are
shielded, the shielding against magnetic field is not as efficient as against
electrical cables. In low frequencies, the twisted pair absorbs most parts of
the effect from electromagnetic interference. In high frequencies these effects
are absorbed by the cable shield. Whenever possible, connect the cable boxes on
the equipotential line system.
Figure 24 – Protection of
transients with the use of metal ducts
Transient and effective distances
protectors
In regard to projects and installations we
must be aware when dealing with concepts and techniques for the protection of
PROFIBUS DP and PROFIBUS PA field equipment in terms of high voltage signals
and induced lightning or other sources.
It is public knowledge that control systems
installations may include of air distribution
and underground cables, wire boxes, cables near to high voltage cables subject
to the exposition to lightning, electrostatic discharges and electromagnetic
interference (EMI). EMI may be radiated (via air), conducted (via conductors),
induced (above 30 MHz) or a combination of these means. For an idea of the
voltage generated by electrostatic discharge, if we consider a conductor with
50nH of inductance, it may include voltage peaks around 200V (V=L*dj/dt) or more, since the current
pulse generated by the electric discharge has a very short upward time,
approximately 4A/ns.
This exposition can affect the behavior of
the signals and damage the equipment, as long as they have the same low power
components and may easily burn with the overvoltage.
What is a transient protector?
The transient protector is a protection
hardware that, properly positioned (as we will see next) and installed,
protects the equipment by limiting the level of the transients that could reach
it. It works almost instantaneously and “deviate” the transient to the ground
and controls the voltage at a level that does not damage the equipment
connected to it. When the current reaches an acceptable level, the normal
operation is automatically reestablished.
A large variety of models is sold in the
market. These protection devices are based on a combination of components like
gas discharge tubes (GDTs, or surge arresters, cutting diodes (clamping
voltage) and metal-oxide varistors (MOVs) whose
features are fast operation, precise voltage control and automatic return, as
soon as the overvoltage stops.
Figure 25 – Surge
Arrester
How to protect PROFIBUS PA networks and
equipment
In PROFIBUS PA installations, the voltages
exceeding normal operation conditions are known as ‘surges’. They appear
transitorily and may affect the network behavior. It is worth mentioning that
as every fieldbus network, they exchange data and, most importantly, they
guarantee the integrity of the data and the plant operational safety.
The longest the PROFIBUS PA network trunk
and derivations, the larger will be the magnitude of transients due to the
ground potential difference. Significant damage can be caused in equipment
connected by short cables if the circuits or components are particularly
sensitive. In some situations, there may be serious damage on the installation
and the equipment, depending on the energy.
The standard PROFIBUS PA network cable is
the twisted pair type, whose twisted conductors minimize
the voltage between lines, although, as mentioned before, the ground potential
difference may damage the components and affect their work, thereby turning the
system sensitive. Also notice that the cable and its distribution are factors
to be considered to minimize noises and transients. The use of shield is
recommended, as it acts as a Faraday cage, and when grounded at the source of
signal it maximizes its efficiency against noises in common mode. Furthermore,
it provides better EMI protection.
Figure 26 – PROFIBUS PA
twisted pair cable
Concerning the transient protector, the
limit voltage must not be higher than the equipment work voltage and in
practice this voltage is used as twice that of the equipment. In
terms of lightning, studies show that the discharges may generate currents from
2 kA to 200 kA on the peak currents lasting less than 10μs.
The choice of the transient protector must
be judicious, as it can degrade the PROFIBUS PA signal and limit the quantity
of equipment. Depending on the manufacturer, this device may add capacity and
resistance to the PROFIBUS PA network and these may affect the communication
wave signal. Furthermore, some cutting diodes could not be transparent on the
network and could also affect the signal levels. In practice, the user should
choose devices that comply with the IEC 61643-21 standard and provide high
surge currents (around 10 kA), while adding less than
1? and less than 40pF to the wiring.
Figure 27 – Distances
recommended in PROFIBUS wiring
Figure 28 – Degree of
interference on a Profibus signal.
The degree of cable interference will
depend on a series of factors such as project, construction and
characteristics, in addition to their interaction with other elements on the
PROFIBUS network (connectors, equipment, shielding, other cables, etc.) besides certain system parameters and
environment properties. A variety of factors limit the performance of the
digital signals transmitted related to the cables, which should be considered
in the project and their use, such as:
o differential
noise (circuit characteristics);
o
longitudinal noise (interference due to electric power supply);
o
impulse noise;
o diaphony (crosstalk);
o
distortions by propagation delay;
o jitter
(phase noise).
What is effective distance?
Effective distance is the physical
separation of two devices grounded during the network installation. Whenever
the effective distance is bigger than 100 m on the horizontal or 10 m on the
vertical between two grounded points, transient protectors are recommended at
the initial and the final distance points. In practice, the use is recommended
between 50 and 100 m.
Figure 29 – Use of
transient protector and the effective distance.
Figure 30 – Example of
PROFIBUS PA protector transient.
How to protect PROFIBUS DP networks and equipment
The rule for effective distance also
applies to the PROFIBUS DP network and equipment.
According to figure 31, protection will be
provided in case of tension drop or when a surge or even any
differential surge should exceed the breakdown voltage. According to
figure 32, this protection is recommended when grounding is not possible and
any differential surge will be converted into common mode.
Figure 31 –
Protection with ground insulation.
Figure 32 – Protection
with common-mode insulation.
Interferences
The interferences on digital network cables
and the instrumentation may be due to:
Electrostatic interferences may be reduced
by:
Electromagnetic Inferences can be
reduced with:
Basically there are 4 types of
interferences:
o
Generated by an electromagnetic source
o Corona
Effect, Line Noise and Sparking
o
Generated by the signal fundamental
o Signal
harmonics or undesirable signals
Let us now
comment on the Corona effect. Inverter cables load the energy of the
speed control motor into the AC motor. These cables should support not only the
high power from the MLP signals (Modulation of Pulse Width), but also the
voltage that occurs when the stationary waves develop in the conductors because
the cable impedance does not match the motor impedance and that from modern
switching inverters. The high voltage may cause Effect Corona discharges and
damage the cables and the inverter variable startup.
Currently, special cables use a thicker,
electrically more stable insulation. The insulation increases the distance
between the conductors and decreases the danger of a Corona Effect discharge.
In addition, by reducing the capacitance, the amplitude of the stationary waves
is reduced, as well as the transference of noises to the ground loop.
Profibus grounding, shielding and
equipotentialization
The ideal grounding condition in a plant
and its installations is when the same potential is found in any point. This
may be reached by connecting all its grounding systems through a potential
equalization conductor. This condition is known as equipotentialization.
So, any person inside a facility will be
free from electric shock, even if the existing voltages increase, because every
element will have the same ground potential.
When referring to shielding and grounding,
in practice there are other ways of dealing with this subject - a very
controversial one - such as, the shield grounding can be done in each station
through the 9-pin sub D connector, whose housing touches the shield at this
point and it is grounded when connected. This situation, however, should be
analyzed timely and the potential graduation of the groundings checked at each
point and equalized. The equipotential line system is used to balance the
ground potential in different plant locations so that no current circulates
over the cable shield.
♦ Copper:
6 mm²
♦ Aluminum: 16 mm²
♦ Steel: 50 mm²
In hazardous areas always observe the
recommendation from the certifying organs and the installation techniques
required by the area classification. An intrinsically safe system must have
components to be grounded and others not. Grounding has the function to avoid
unsafe voltages from appearing in classified areas. Avoid to ground
intrinsically safe components unless required for functional
purposes when using galvanic insulation. The minimum insulation established by
standards is 500 Vca. The resistance between the
ground terminal and ground system must be below 1Ω. In Brazil, the installation
in potentially explosive atmospheres is regulated by the NBR-5418 standard.
For grounding, it is recommended grouping
circuits and equipment together with similar noise characteristics in serial
distribution and uniting these points on a parallel reference. Always ground conduits and boxes.
In hazardous areas always observe the
recommendation from the certifying organs and the installation techniques
required by the area classification. An intrinsically safe system must have
components to be grounded and others not. Grounding has the function to avoid
unsafe voltages from appearing in classified areas. Avoid to ground
intrinsically safe components unless required for functional
purposes when using galvanic insulation. The minimum insulation established by
standards is 500 Vca. The resistance between the
ground terminal and ground system must be below 1Ω. In Brazil, the installation
in potentially explosive atmospheres is regulated by the NBR-5418 standard.
For grounding, it is recommended grouping
circuits and equipment together with similar noise characteristics in serial
distribution and uniting these points on a parallel reference. Always ground conduits and boxes.
A common error is the use o protection ground as signal ground. Remember that this
ground is very noisy and may present high impedance. Recommended is the use of
grounding loops, as they have low impedance. Common high frequency conductors
present the disadvantage of having high impedance. Current loops should be
avoided. The ground system must be regarded as a circuit that supplies the
current flow with the least possible impedance. The minimum ground value
recommended is below 10 Ω.
The shield (the loop as well as the
aluminum blade) should be connected to the functional ground system via the
PROFIBUS-DP connector, so that it provides a wide connection area with the
conductive surface grounded.
When extending the cable,
be careful so that the shield finishing is well done and is not contacting
other points unless the grounding points. The maximum protection
is at the grounded points, which provide a low impedance route to the high frequency
signals.
In cases with a voltage differential
between the grounding points, such as different areas in separated facilities,
locate a potential equalization line next to the
wiring, by using the proper metal conduit or an AWG 10012 cable. (See Figure 33).
This will provide the most effective
protection for a wide frequency band.
Figure 33 – Equipotential
line
Figure 33 – Detail of wiring in different
areas with equalized ground potentials
Figure 34 shows wiring,
shield and ground details in different areas.
Figure 33 – Detail of
wiring in different areas with equalized ground potentials
Profibus-PA network
When considering the
question of shield and grounding on fied buses, take
into account:
According to IEC 61158-2,
to ground means to be permanently connected to the ground by a sufficiently low
impedance and with enough conductive capacity to prevent any voltage from
causing damages to equipment or persons. Voltage lines with 0 Volts must be
connected to ground and galvanically insulated from
the fieldbus bus. The purpose of grounding the shield is to avoid high
frequency noises.
Preferably, the shield
must be grounded on two points, a the beginning and
the end of the bus, provided there is no difference potential between these
points and allows the existence and paths to loop currents. In practice, when
this difference exists, ground the shield only at a single point, i.e., the power
source or the intrinsic safety barrier. Make sure the continuity of the
shielded cable is longer than 90% of the cable total length.
The shield must cover
entirely the electric circuits through the connectors, couplings, splices and
junction and distribution boxes.
Never use the
shield as a signal conductor. Always verify the shield continuity until the
last PA segment in the segment, with due analysis of the connection and
finishing, as it should not be grounded on the equipment housing.
In classified areas, if
the equalization potential between the safe and the hazardous areas is not
possible, the shield must be connected directly to ground (Equipotential
Bonding System) only at the hazardous area side. At the safe area, the shield
must be connected by a capacitive coupling, preferably a dielectric solid
ceramic capacitor, C<= 10nF, isolation voltage >= 1.5kV).
Figure 35 – Shield and Ground Ideal Combination
Figure 36 – Capacitive
Grounding
The IEC 61158-2
recommends the complete insulation. This method is used mainly in the U.S. and
U.K. In this instance, the shield is insulated on all grounds, with exception
to the negative ground point of the power source or the intrinsic safety
barrier on the safe side. The shield has continuity from the DP/PA coupler
output, passes along the junction and distribution boxes and reaches the
equipment. The equipment housings are grounded individually on the non-safe
side. This method has the disadvantage that it does not protect totally the
high frequency signals and, depending on the topology and cable length, may
generate occasional communication intermittence. In these cases, the use of
metal ducts is recommended.
Another additional manner
is to ground the equipment junction boxes and housings on a ground
equipotential line on the non-safe side. The grounds on the non-safe and safe
sides are separated.
Multiple grounding is
also usual and provides more effective protection on situations of high
frequency and electromagnetic noises. This method is preferably adopted in
Germany and some Europeran countries. In this method,
the shield is grounded on the ground point of the power source or the safe side
of the intrinsic safety barrier, besides the ground on the equipment junction
boxes and housings, and is also grounded on the non-safe side. An additional an complementary situation is one whose grounds would be
grounded in a set on an equipotential ground line, connecting the non-safe side
to the safe side.
For more details, always refer to the local
safety standards. The IEC 60079-14 is recommended as a reference for
applications on classified areas.
Figure 37 – Grounding and
Shield– Several types
Cautions and
recommendations with grounding and shield on the PROFIBUS-DP bus
The shield (the loop and
the aluminum blade) must be connected to the system functional ground on all
stations through the connector and DP cable) to provide a large connection area
with the grounded conductive surface.
Maximum protection is
provided with all points grounded through a low impedance path to the high
frequency signals.
In cases with voltage diferential between the grounding points, pass close to the
wiring an equalization potential line (the metal duct or an AWG 10-12 cable can
be used). See figure 33.
Figure 38 – Equipotential
Line
In terms of wiring use
the twisted pair of wires with 100% of the shield covered. The best conditions
for the shield work are met with at least 80% covered.
When referring to shield
and grounding, in practice there are other ways of handling this subject, one
with much controversy, as for example, the shield grounding can be made in each
station with the sub D 9-pin connector (figure 34), where the connector
housing makes contact with the shield and is grounded when connecting with
the station. In this case, though, annalyze and
verify punctually the ground graduation potential and, if necessary, equalize
it.
In hazardous areas always
use the recommendations from the certifying bodies and the installation
techniques demanded by the area classification. An intrinsically safe system
should have components that must be grounded and others not. The purpose of
grounding is to avoid occurring unsafe voltages on the classified area. On
classified areas, avoid grounding intrinsically safe components, unless it is
necessary for functional reasons, when employing galvanic insulation. The
standards establish the minimum insulation of 500V resistance between the
ground terminal, while the system ground must be lower
than 1Ω. In Brazil, the installation on potentially explosive atmospheres is
regulated by the NBR-5418.
An extra caution should
be taken against excessive termination. Some devices have on-board termination.
Figure 39 – Detail of a
typical Sub D 9-Pin connector
Figure 33 presents wiring,
shield and grounding details on multiple areas.
For grounding, group
circuits and equipment with similar noise characteristics in serial
distribution and connect these points on a parallel reference and also ground
ducts and boxes.
A common error is the use
of protection ground as signal ground. It is worth noting that this ground is
too noisy and may present high impedance. An interesting alternative is the use
of grounding loops, as they present low impedance. Common high frequency
conductors have the disadvantage of having high impedance and current loops
should be avoided. The grounding system should be seen as a circuit that favors
the flow of current under the minimum possible inductance. The ground value
should be lower than 10 Ω.
Use of shielded cables to minimize noises
In order to provide better efficiency
against noises, the double shield (twist and foil) has been applied with
considerable improvement in the signal/noise relationship. The following can be
added:
·
Double protection most certainly provides more efficiency, in some cases even
three-fold. The more closed the loop, the better the protection.
·
The twisted shield and the foil can be applied in different ways, for low and
high frequencies.
For low frequencies the cable
is grounded in only one of the ends and in these frequencies the shield is
expected to present the same potential. This would provide more protection in
low-frequency noises.
For high frequencies the
shield will present high susceptibility to noise and both ends should be
grounded, although some precaution should be taken due to equipotentiality
and safety.
This double protection alternative would
protect both low and high frequencies, providing better EMI protection.
The efficacy of the loop (shield) is
generally better in low frequencies, while the foil is more efficient in higher
frequencies.
Concerning inverters, which normally are a
source of noises, an important point is that most of them have commutation
frequency ranging from 1kHz to 30 kHz. In addition,
some inverter manufacturers state they comply with the
CE standards, but that in adequate installations mandatory is:
1. Properly ground,
according to manuals, i.e., the shield is grounded on both ends and the motor
housing is also grounded (per manufacturers´ recommendation).
2. Output power, control
wiring (I/O) and signal must use shielded cable, twisted with original cover
equal to or above 75%, with metal conduit or equivalent attenuation.
3. All shielded cables
must have their ends in an adequate shielded connector.
4. The control and signal
cables must be separated at least 0.3 m from power wiring.
How to understand the Profibus
signal reflection
RS485 physical means is the standard with
two independent channels known as A and B that transmit
equal voltage levels, however with opposed polarity (VOA and VOB)
or simply VA and VB).
For this reason, the network must be
activated with the correct polarity. Although with opposed signals, one does
not work as return for the other, i.e. there is no current loop.
Each signal returns through ground or a
third return conductor, but the signal must be read by the receptor in a
differential way without reference to the ground or the return conductor.
This is the great advantage of the
differential signal concerning ground in this communication system: note on
figure 41 that the signal is running with
inverted phases on the cable conductors, while the noise runs with the same
phase.
On the input terminals of the differential
amplifier the Profibus communication signal reaches
in differential mode and the noise reaches in common mode, hence rejecting it.
Therefore, all noise induced in the cable, generally from electromagnetic
origin, will be mostly rejected.
Figure 41 – RS485 Profibus-DP signal
Figure 42 – RS485 Profibus-DP network
Differential transmission lines use as
information only the difference of potential that exists between the two
twisted pair conductors, regardless of the potential difference presented in
relation to voltage referential (common or ground
referential).
What is signal reflection?
Signal reflection occurs when a signal is
transmitted along a means of transmission such as a copper cable or optics
fiber and part of the signal energy may be reflected back to its origin. It may
be due to a cable imperfection, change of impedance along the communication
line (splices), lack of terminator spur beyond permitted, total length beyond
permitted, etc.
Figure 43 – Profibus signal without reflection (left) and with
reflection (right) due to lack of terminator
Figure 44- Profibus signal with reflection by splices (left) and
without reflection (right).
Note on figure 45 that the largest the communicaton rate, the largest the reflection influence
will be, as the bit time is smaller.
Figure 45 – Profibus signal with reflections in different baud rates.
Figure 47 shows an example of
installation whose minimum curve was violated and makes the Profibus
signal act like that on figure 48.
Minimum curvature
Flexion, stretching,
twisting, crushing while installing the Profibus
cable may force the conductors or even alter their transversal sections. This disturbs the common
axis of the conductors and their shield, and fakes a change of impedance on the
cable stress points. By capturing the signals, these points are easily
identified by the reflections on the signals. Nonetheless, the minimum
specified radius refers to the cable internal surface and not the cable axis.
Figure 46 – Minimum Curvature Radius
Frequently the damages are not visible and
the cable insulation and integrity may be impaired.
Figure 47 – Examples of
inadequate minimum curvatures and damaged cables
Figure 48 – Profibus signal with reflection due to the violation of the
cable minimum curvature
Figure 49 shows the diagram of a
basic single-ended transmission line. A voltage source (VS) generates a digital
signal with a Zs impedance.
The transmission line has the AC impedance ZO in relation to the ground and at
the cable end there is the ZT impedance, for impedance matching. Profibus has a terminator at the beginning and the end of
each segment that guarantees the best signal condition.
Figure 49 – Diagram of a
basic (single ended) transmission line
What is a network terminator?
The terminator is an
impedance added to the Profibus line with the
function of matching the network impedance. The longer the network length is,
the bigger the signal distortion. The terminator eliminates communication
errors caused by the distorted signals. If the terminator is not installed, the
wiring will work as an antenna, hence facilitating signal distortions and
increasing the susceptibility to noises. The characteristic impedance is the
load value, which placed at the end of this line does not reflect any energy.
In other words, it is the load value that provides the zero reflection coefficient, or still, a relation of stationary waves equal
to one.
Without any terminators at the Profibus segment, the resulting signal in the load is
distorted in time (jitter) and amplitude (oscillations). Every time the cable
geometry is altered it will cause unbalanced impedance and resulting
reflections.
Both Profibus-DP
and Profibus-PA networks require terminators. The use
of a bus terminator is mandatory where its absence may cause unbalance, with
the resulting propagation delay, as well as the damped resonance oscillations
cause the transposition of the logical level (thresholds). In addition, the
static noise margin improves. In the Profibus-DP, the
terminators are active ones, i.e. they are powered. See figure 50.
Figure 50 – Profibus-DP bus terminator.
The active termination is needed at the
beginning and the end of each bus segment in order to keep the communication
signal integrity and both terminator should be powered. See figure 51.
Figure 51 – Profibus-DP active bus terminator.
The Profibus-DP
must have bus terminators (a 100 Ohm resistor and a serial 1 uF) one at the beginning and other at the end. The shield must
not be connected to the terminator and the impedance must be 100 ohms +/-20%
from 7.8 to 39 kHz. This value is approximately the average value of the
characteristic cable impedance on the work frequencies and it is chosen to
minimize the transmission line reflections, as well as to convert the signal in
acceptable 750 to 1000 mV levels.
Figure 52a – Typical PA
network wave form and the influence of the terminators.
Figure 52b – PA
terminator with signals of humidity: wrong termination.
Necessary care with the Profibus-DP
network terminators
As terminators are active devices, a common
error is to place the work stations as a DP slave where an energy drop or a
microcomputer is reset, causing unbalance on the
power supply lines, intermittence and undesirable timeouts.
Shielding
Grounding and shielding
are mandatory requirements to guarantee the integrity of a plant data. In
practice, it is very common to watch intermittent work and gross errors in
measurements due to the bad installations.
Noise effects can be
minimized with adequate techniques of projects, installation, cable
distribution, grounding and shielding. Inadequate
grounding may be the source of undesirable and dangerous potentials that may
endanger the effective operation of an equipment or
the work system itself.
The shield must be connected to the signal
reference potential of what is being protected (see figure 53).
Figure 53 – Shielding
connected to the signal reference potential it protects
When there are multiple
segments keep them connected, ensuring the same reference potential, according
to figure 54.
Figure 54 –
Multiple-segment shielding connected to the signal reference potential it is
protecting
Grounding effect vs.
Single-point grounding
In this case the current
will not circulate through the loop and will not cancel the magnetic fields.
The length of the conductor extending outside the shield should be minimized
and guarantee good connection between the ground and the shield.
Figure 27- Grounding
Effect vs single-point grounding
Grounding effect vs Two-point grounding
A distribution of
currents occurs here, in function of the frequencies, since the current tends
to follow the course of lower impedance.
Up to a few kHz: the inductive
reactance is neglectable and the current will
circulate by the way of less resistance.
Above kHz: the inductive
reactance predominates and this will make the current circulate by the way of
less inductance.
The way of less impedance
is that whose course of return is close to the course of departure for
presenting distributed capacitance and lower distributed inductance.
The length of the
conductor extending outside the conductor should be minimized and guarantee
good connection between the the shield and the
ground.
Figure 28
- Grounding effect vs two-point grounding
It is worth mentioning in
this case:
1. There is no protection
against ground loops.
2. Significant damages may
be caused to active equipment when the ground potential difference between both
ends goes beyond 1 V (rms).
3. The grounding electrical
resistance should be the lowest possible on both segment ends to minimize the
ground loops, mainly in low frequencies.
The cable grounding is
used to eliminate interferences by capacitive coupling due to electrical
fields.
The shielding is only
efficient when it establishes a low impedance path to the ground.
A floating shielding does
not proctect against interferences.
The grounding loop must
be connected to the ground reference potential that is bening
shielded.
Ground the shield on more
than one point may be problematic.
Minimize the length of
the shield-reference connection, as it works as a coil.
Figure 29 – The length of
the ground-reference connection should be minimized as it works as a coil.
Some general rules
concerning control panels, MCCs and instrumentation
Conclusion
This article showed multiple details on
grounding, shielding, noises, interferences and reflections. Every network
project must take into consideration the standards required to guarantee
adequate signal levels, as well as the safety needed for the application.
Annually, preventive maintenance actions
should be adopted to check each ground system connection, in order to ensure
quality regarding robustness, reliability and low impedance, and guarantee that
there is no contamination and corrosion.
This article does not replace the NBR 5410,
the HBR 5418, the IEC 61158 and IEC 61784 standards nor
the PROFIBUS profiles and technical manuals. In case of discrepancy or doubts,
all the above standards and manufacturers manuals will prevail. Whenever
possible consult the EN50170 for physical regulations, as well as the safety
practices for each area.